PeopleAboutPortfolioInsights
Contact
Go back
December 19, 2019
Posted by
RMI Investment Managers

2019: An Industry Review

The year 2019 provided investors with some respite after what was an especially trying 2018.

South African equities returned 10.5% over the year to end-October 2019, a stark contrast to the -8.5% seen in 2018’s calendar year which was one of the market’s worst performances in the last 10 years. Domestic bonds returned 8.1%, also performing even better than in 2018 when they gained 7.7%. The period was characterised by much uncertainty from both a local and international perspective. As a result, significant de-risking took place to the benefit of the fixed income market and some parts of the equity market, precious metals in particular.

The economic backdrop over the year was somewhat mixed. Investors had to contend with the ongoing trade war between the US and China and questionable global growth prospects, but central bank policy accommodation was supportive of risk sentiment. Closer to home, investors have been on tenterhooks about the potential downgrade of South Africa’s debt to junk status given issues with state-owned enterprises, Eskom and frequent power cuts in particular. Further evidence of governance issues and misconduct at various corporates weighed on risk appetite too. These factors all contributed to the risk-off sentiment seen in the South African market this year.

Risk-off environment favours resources and bonds

It is unsurprising therefore that in this environment, the resources sector posted strong performance as investors turned to gold in their search for perceived safe haven assets. The yellow metal has gained 18% year-to-date (US dollars, to end-October 2019) while the gold mining stocks index is up over 100%. The rebound of the resources sector accounts for 62% of the JSE’s overall return and means that the local bourse has done better than many of its emerging market counterparts. However, returns are still behind that of global equities (26.2%), whose gains can largely be attributed to the continued equity bull run in the US.

The domestic fixed income market also benefited from the risk-off environment. While performance came in slightly behind that of the equity market, it was ahead of global bonds thanks to the continued attraction of the country’s high yielding instruments as compared to much of the developed world where yields are low to negative.

Boutiques outperform

‍ Against this backdrop, we have seen boutique managers do well compared to their bank/insurer-linked peers. According to Morningstar data (performance ranking over three years to end October), 54% of listed equity portfolios managed by boutiques have generated first or second quartile performance compared to 50% in the case of bank/insurer- linked managers. For the most part, RMI IM’s affiliates have outperformed their peers too. Of the 23 CIS portfolios with a 3-year track record managed by RMI IM’s affiliates, 80% posted first or second quartile performance. Year-to-date and over 12 months, 61% have outperformed their ASISA category peers.

Figure 1. Independent boutiques have outperformed bank/insurer-linked counterparts

Bond portfolios a beneficiary of industry flows

Looking at industry assets, market moves, and net inflows helped the industry post growth of 9.2% over the first three quarters of the year. Net inflows (including ASISA’s regional, global and worldwide categories) totalled R127.2 billion, compared to R79.8 billion over the same period last year. Fixed income managers saw large inflows; as an asset class, Fixed Income portfolios experienced the fastest growth over a 12-month and three-year period to end-September.

Figure 2. Industry asset growth
Figure 3. One, three and seven-year CAGRs for ASISA categories

That said, multi-asset remains the most popular destination for retail investors, holding 43% of total assets under management.

Figure 4. Assets under management by ASISA category

‍Challengers outperform CIA and Contenders again

Boutiques have received a healthy share of the industry inflows. The below chart illustrates this by plotting the quarterly flows attributed to each of the three categories we use to assess the asset management industry. The categories are: banks and insurers, the CIA firms (which includes the likes of Coronation, Investec and Allan Gray); the Contender firms (PSG, Prudential, Foord, Sygnia, Prescient and Abax) and then the Challenger group, which is made up of the smaller managers like the RMI IM affiliates.

While banks and insurers have attracted the lion’s share of net flows, the Challenger group holds second position, outperforming both the Contender and CIA firms by some margin. Compared to last year, the Challengers have also posted impressive growth: in 2018 quarterly, net flows totalled approximately R18 billion over the first three quarters of the year, versus the R41 billion recorded over the same period this year.

Figure 5. Quarterly net flows by category (excl. money market)

‍Known unknowns

Looking forward into the new decade, there are a number of “known unknowns” that lie ahead; issues we know about but the outcomes of which are highly uncertain.  Will South African debt be downgraded to junk status? Is it possible the US and China reach a mutually beneficial trade agreement? Will the global economy tip into a recession? Who will win the US presidential election?

With so many unanswered questions, the outlook for 2020 is anything but certain. One thing is for sure though: there’ll be plenty of “unknown unknowns” to take us by surprise too. We have every faith that our affiliates will keep their heads about them as they navigate through the year, and we have no doubt that they will remain committed to generating the best returns possible for their clients as well as growing and transforming the asset management industry.

Share this story:

Facebook
Instagram
Whatsapp
X
Copy link
Previous post
Back to insights
Next post
Back to insights
Leading Insights

Our insights can move thinking.

See more
See more
21
October 2024
The risks and potential downsides of tokenisation for asset managers and investors in South Africa
12
September 2023
Momentum Metropolitan acquires RMI Investment Managers
9
December 2022
In another tough year, market boutiques continue to shine
9
December 2021
Portfolio performances and future outlook
14
December 2020
A Year Like No Other: 2020 A Year in Review
20
March 2020
Culture: A Key Determinant of good Client Outcomes
19
March 2020
How much do you think about your equity fund’s benchmark?
19
December 2019
2019: An Industry Review
11
July 2019
Championing the gender agenda
11
July 2019
ESG investing: A self-fulfilling prophecy?
1
April 2019
Partnership formalised with Perpetua Investment Managers
1
April 2019
A journey of Discovery: From humble beginnings to 100 million healthier lives
1
April 2019
How many women are managing your money?
6
December 2018
Trying times: 2018 industry review
6
December 2018
Culture matters and that’s the bottom line
22
August 2018
What matters most when allocating to boutique managers?
22
August 2018
The Next Frontier: a #NewFundOrder
22
August 2018
Pension Fund Act Amendments – The “Uber” moment for financial service advisors?
23
April 2018
The Best of Both Worlds
15
March 2018
Finding the Yin and the Yang
8
March 2018
AI Looms Over the City: Godzilla Approaches
8
March 2018
The Crypto Gold Rush
8
March 2018
SharingAlpha: An interview with Oren Kaplan
IMG Logo
PeopleAboutPortfolioInsights
Contact
Investment Managers Group (Pty) Ltd. All rights reserved 2020
•
2nd Floor, Ou Kollege Gebou, 35 Church Street, Stellenbosch, 7600
Privacy Policy
•
PAIA Manual
•
Cookie Preferences
IMG color strip
By clicking "Accept", you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyse site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. View our Privacy Policy for more information.
Preferences
DenyAccept

Privacy Preference Center

When you visit websites, they may store or retrieve data in your browser. This storage is often necessary for the basic functionality of the website. The storage may be used for marketing, analytics, and personalization of the site, such as storing your preferences. Privacy is important to us, so you have the option of disabling certain types of storage that may not be necessary for the basic functioning of the website. Blocking categories may impact your experience on the website.
Allow all cookiesReject all cookies

Manage Consent Preferences by Category

Essential
Always Active
These items are required to enable basic website functionality.
Marketing
These items are used to deliver advertising that is more relevant to you and your interests. They may also be used to limit the number of times you see an advertisement and measure the effectiveness of advertising campaigns. Advertising networks usually place them with the website operator’s permission.
Personalization
These items allow the website to remember choices you make (such as your user name, language, or the region you are in) and provide enhanced, more personal features. For example, a website may provide you with local weather reports or traffic news by storing data about your current location.
Analytics
These items help the website operator understand how its website performs, how visitors interact with the site, and whether there may be technical issues. This storage type usually doesn’t collect information that identifies a visitor.
Confirm my preferences